Warm, updated living room with an oatmeal sofa, walnut coffee table and large window overlooking mature trees in late autumn.

Indian Hill's Past Year of Sales, Read House by House

1554 Chickasaw Drive came on the market in June 2025 at $600,000. Over the summer the price dropped to $575,000. The house went under contract in September at $550,000 and closed on October 16, 2025, for $502,000.

The same house returned this fall after what the listing calls a fully permitted renovation. The kitchen now has white shaker cabinets, quartz counters and new stainless appliances. Every bathroom was updated, the main level has new flooring, and the furnace and air conditioner are new. The roof dates to 2024. It was relisted September 2 at $739,700 and cut to $729,700 on September 10. MRED MLS records show it going under contract on November 8, about nine and a half weeks after it was relisted.

The 2,259 square feet and the 0.23-acre lot didn't change. Between the two listings the house gained a finished interior, and its last asking price sits about $228,000 above its 2025 sale price. It also came back after Labor Day and needed more than two months to find a buyer, roughly three weeks faster than its unrenovated first run, which went from a June listing to a September contract. Indian Hill's other sales over the past year follow the same pattern. Buyers here pay well for a finished house in the subdivision's usual footprint when it's listed in spring. Size beyond that footprint, and a listing date after midsummer, earn a lot less. For someone shopping now, that means the pricing advantage has moved to the buyer's side of the table.

Two houses on Chickasaw, eight months apart

1525 Chickasaw Drive is a 1972 house with five bedrooms and 3,780 square feet, the largest home to sell in Indian Hill during the past year. It was not a fixer. Its listing describes a kitchen fully updated in 2024 with quartz counters, both upstairs bathrooms remodeled the same year, new windows and fresh paint inside and out, and a new furnace and air conditioner installed in June 2025. It was listed July 12, 2025, at $679,000 and later reduced to $659,000. It sold November 18, 2025, for $605,000 after 94 days, at 92% of list. That works out to about $160 per square foot.

1527 Chickasaw Drive is a 1973 house with 2,580 square feet, about 1,200 fewer. It has a remodeled kitchen with quartz counters, new windows and skylights, siding and gutters replaced in 2025, and an in-ground pool on a fenced lot. It sold on June 30, 2026, for $735,000 after three days on market, at 101% of list. That's about $285 per square foot.

So the smaller house brought $130,000 more. Both were updated, but they went to market at different times of year, and one was much larger than nearly everything around it. The two causes are tangled together, and a sample this small can't separate them cleanly. Still, in this sale the extra 1,200 square feet traded at well below the subdivision's typical per-foot price, even with the updates already in place.

The year in eight closings

MRED MLS records show eight Indian Hill closings between November 15, 2025, and November 15, 2026. The median was $622,500 and the range ran from $575,000 to $750,000.

Closed Address Sq ft Sale price Share of list
Nov 18, 2025 1525 Chickasaw Drive 3,780 $605,000 92%
Jan 9, 2026 1528 Shenandoah Lane 2,159 $595,000 99%
May 1, 2026 1013 Iroquois Avenue 2,403 $615,000 103%
May 15, 2026 1549 Chippewa Drive 2,401 $630,000 107%
Jun 8, 2026 610 Pawnee Lane 2,181 $575,000 96%
Jun 15, 2026 509 Ticonderoga Lane 2,559 $750,000 100%
Jun 30, 2026 1527 Chickasaw Drive 2,580 $735,000 101%
Jul 21, 2026 908 Kennebec Lane 1,857 $635,000 106%

Six of the eight closed between May and July, and the listings behind them came on in April and May. 1549 Chippewa Drive was listed April 9 at $590,000 and closed at $630,000. Its listing points to an updated kitchen, a remodeled primary bath, a new driveway and a new deck. 1013 Iroquois Avenue, a 1985 original-owner house with newer windows, doors, roof and HVAC, was listed the same day at $599,900 and closed May 1 at $615,000. 509 Ticonderoga Lane came on April 22 at $750,000 and sold at exactly that price on June 15. Its listing leads with a redesigned kitchen that has a large island, quartz counters and a walk-in pantry, an unusual feature in a house of that era.

The smallest house on the list shows how much condition is worth. 908 Kennebec Lane, a 1971 house with 1,857 square feet, was described as updated and move-in ready. It went under contract in five days and closed in July at $635,000, 106% of its list price. That's $30,000 more than the 3,780-square-foot house on Chickasaw brought the previous November.

The low end of the range came from a spring sale too. 610 Pawnee Lane, 2,181 square feet and built in 1972, was listed May 12 at $599,000 and closed June 8 at $575,000. So timing alone doesn't set the price. The houses that went over list in spring all came with an updated kitchen or newer major systems that the listing could name.

Where the ceiling sits

None of the eight sales broke $750,000. The two that came closest, 509 Ticonderoga and 1527 Chickasaw, are both 1970s houses of about 2,550 to 2,600 square feet with remodeled kitchens, and both sold in June. Their prices were about $293 and $285 per square foot. Over the 12-month window, the median across the subdivision was $270 per square foot.

That's useful context for the renovated 1554 Chickasaw. Its last asking price of $729,700 on 2,259 square feet works out to about $323 per square foot. Only one closed sale in the past year went higher per foot: 908 Kennebec, at about $342 on its smaller 1,857 square feet. 1554 Chickasaw is under contract and hasn't closed, so its final price is still unknown. Priced near the $735,000 to $750,000 top of the range, it took a $10,000 cut and about nine and a half weeks to reach a contract in the fall.

For context, Naperville's citywide median for detached homes was $718,500 on 108 sales in April 2026, as Chicago Agent Magazine reported. Indian Hill's 12-month median sits about $100,000 below that, in a north Naperville subdivision close to Arrowhead Park, I-88 and downtown. For more on the parks and errands around the subdivision, see our earlier piece on how Indian Hill fits together without a main street.

Why the fall clock runs slower here

Across Naperville, the market softened only a little after spring. MRED-based data for all property types put the city's average days on market at 16 in April 2026 and 22 in October 2026. Over the same months the sale-to-original-list ratio slipped from 99.7% to 97.8%, and active listings rose from 229 to 345. Demand didn't collapse either. Chicago Agent Magazine reported 116 detached-home sales in Naperville in September 2026, up from 86 in September 2025.

Indian Hill's late-season listings ran much slower than those citywide averages. 1525 Chickasaw took 94 days from a July listing. 1554 Chickasaw took about four months to sell in 2025 and about nine and a half weeks to reach a contract in 2026. And no Indian Hill closings show up between August and mid-November 2026. A subdivision that turns over about eight houses a year doesn't have a deep bench of buyers on any given weekend. In spring, two or three of them can show up for the same house and push it past list. In fall, a seller may wait for the one buyer whose timing happens to line up.

What's on the market heading into winter

Three Indian Hill homes were listed as active in mid-November. Two have already been reduced.

517 Menominee Lane is a 1976 four-bedroom with 2,257 square feet. Its listing mentions a new roof, gutters and sump pump. It came on November 3 at $599,000 and is now $575,000. 620 Iroquois Avenue is a 1973 three-bedroom with 1,887 square feet on 0.241 acres. It has a 2026 roof and gutters, a 2022 furnace and air conditioner, and hardwood in the main rooms and all three bedrooms. It was listed September 17 at $560,000 and is now $549,900. 904 Iroquois Avenue, a 1974 house with 2,401 square feet, has been marketed at $650,000 after a substantial 2026 remodel that covered the roof, siding, floors, kitchen, baths and mechanicals. Its status may have changed since early October, so check it before planning a showing.

Read against the past year, these listings say a few things. The two updated houses priced near the old median have already come down, before the holidays and the first real cold. 904 Iroquois is the kind of finished house that brought $735,000 and $750,000 in June, now asking $650,000 in fall. A buyer who wants to be in Indian Hill can expect sellers in late November to discuss price, repairs and closing dates more openly than the April sellers did. The other side of that is selection. You're choosing from three homes, and next spring could bring more competition along with more choice.

If you're selling in Indian Hill, the data points the other way. Kitchens, baths and newer systems are what earned over-list prices here. The calendar mattered nearly as much. Our notes on pricing right in week one explain why the first two weeks on market matter so much in a subdivision this small.

The team at Bill White Homes can compare any Indian Hill house, active or coming in spring, against the eight sales above, one kitchen and one closing date at a time. If you're weighing an offer this winter or a listing in April, get in touch and we'll go through your house street by street, or start with a home valuation.

Work With a Team Built on Trust

EXPERIENCE REAL ESTATE THE RIGHT WAY

Work With a Team Built on Trust

For decades, Bill White Homes has guided clients through every step of the buying and selling process with integrity, care, and proven expertise.

Follow Me on Instagram